Roundup: McCain and Obama Health Plans

As a quick search will reveal, I’ve expressed my vieaw of the presidential candidates’ health care reform plans in several posts over the past few months. Put simply, my belief is that the proposals by Senator John McCain and Senator Barack Obama are both grievously flawed. The winner on November 4th would be far better served repositioning their ideas as a statement of philosophy, principles and concepts rather than a blue print for change. The incoming president should then start with a blank slate and come up with something that might actually to more good than harm.

But that’s just my take on their plans. I thought it might be interesting to pull together in one post links to what others are saying about the plans. I’ve tried to find opinions and blogs from across the political and policy spectrums, but if you think I missed an important perspective, please let me know by writing a comment and providing links of your own.

To get things started, here’s a quick comparison of the McCain and Obama health care reform plans. The Commonwealth Fund offers a more detailed review.

  • John Goodman takes both plans to task (my thanks to Ron Masters for bringing this one to my attention).
  • This post on the Harvard Kennedy School’s site, describes all things wonderful about Senator Obama’s proposal.
  • The PatientAssistanceblog finds things to like in Senator McCain’s plan.
  • The American magazineaccuses Senator Obama of seeking to end private health insurance.
  • The Lewin Group prices out the costs of both plans (such estimates should be taken with huge quantities of salt as another, equally respected group can come up with far different results. It’s sort of similar to why polls differ to much. It’s all in the assumptions.)
  • The Physicians for a National Health Program are advocates of a single-payer health care system. They don’t like either proposal.
  • Voters desire for significant health care reform is noted over at MedPage Today.
  • Richard Locker of the Commercial Appeal (a paper in Memphis) agrees with me that the candidate’s proposals are merely starting points expressing their attitudes toward health care reform. He also explains why many think substantial change is unlikely to emerge from Washington any time soon.

This is far from being an exhaustive list. I’ll probably add more between now and election day and, again, I hope you’ll add to the list by leaving a comment, too.

One thought on “Roundup: McCain and Obama Health Plans

  1. Massachusetts health reform law is a sham and is discrimination based on income.The poor get health care,the wealthy get health care but not the middle incomes. The insurance plans are too exspensive and have high dedutables.The citizens are fined for not buying in.How will the state enforce this law?The fines are “taxes” and unpaid taxes are a jailable offense,will they be jailed for not paying the fines?

Comments are closed.